The “WWE Unreal” documentary series has sparked debate, with some viewing it as an attempt to shatter the remnants of Kayfabe, while others see it as a way to create a new form of it, depending on perspective. The show has received mixed reactions from fans and industry insiders, many of whom worry about how much wrestling’s mystique has been stripped away in recent years.
Bully Ray expressed concern that shows like “Unreal” undermine the audience’s ability to emotionally connect with wrestling storylines. He cited a recent episode of “AEW Dynamite,” highlighting the segment where Christian Cage promoted Nick Wayne by referencing both Wayne’s mother and his deceased father. Ray noted the crowd’s subdued reaction, with fans not responding verbally, and even Christian Cage seeming puzzled about the lack of engagement.
This lack of audience investment is exactly what critics of the WWE Unreal series point to as a problem. Bully Ray acknowledged his business mindset but confessed that his faith in the audience’s willingness to suspend disbelief is fading because the content no longer feels believable.
Alongside fellow host Mark Henry, Bully mentioned that these concerns are shared by many and that their critical stance is not meant to discourage fans but to call out what they see as the consequences of losing authenticity. This isn’t the first time such issues have been raised, as Henry previously admitted feeling uneasy about similar moments in wrestling.
—
Fan Take: This discussion highlights a crucial challenge for AEW and wrestling in general—maintaining genuine audience engagement amidst changes in how stories are told. For AEW fans, preserving the magic of wrestling’s storytelling is vital to the sport’s future, as the emotional connection between performers and fans is what keeps the industry alive.
