WWE’s roster boasts many top-tier stars like Cody Rhodes and Becky Lynch, who have made names for themselves both inside and outside the wrestling realm. However, many talented but underrated wrestlers didn’t get the spotlight they deserve throughout 2025.
As 2026 approaches, WWE has a perfect opportunity to elevate fresh talent. Whether it’s veterans who have been overlooked or younger wrestlers ready to showcase their skills, the company can shake things up and potentially uncover the next breakout star.
8. Omos
- Former RAW Tag Team Champion
- Did not appear on WWE TV in 2025
Omos stands out due to his enormous size, which is rare in WWE. This uniqueness alone warrants giving him more chances, as his imposing presence can intimidate opponents. WWE could position him as a bodyguard or a main singles competitor, and given his charisma, there’s potential for him to become a top star.
7. Natalya
- Often overlooked by WWE
- Created a unique gimmick on the independent circuit
Despite being a veteran, Natalya remains underrated, especially considering her technical wrestling skill and ability to deliver great matches. WWE has mostly used her to support other stars, but 2026 might be the year to explore her independent gimmick more thoroughly and finally give her the recognition she deserves.
6. Ivar
- Should be given another singles run
- A large man with exceptional athleticism
Primarily known as one half of the Viking Raiders tag team, Ivar has the capacity to offer more. Fans remember when his partner Eric briefly went solo after an injury, which raised his own profile. Ivar could fill a role similar to Bronson Reed if WWE gives him the right support.
5. Santos Escobar
- Former Cruiserweight Champion
- Could be featured more heavily in a partnership with AAA
Although fans thought Escobar’s WWE chapter ended earlier in the year, he was re-signed but hasn’t appeared on TV. Escobar is talented in both promo skills and wrestling, and if WWE gives him a chance, he’s likely to impress and deliver compelling performances.
4. JC Mateo
- Part of the Solo Chikoa faction
- Has limited solo opportunities
Mateo is a seasoned performer with success in Japan and Lucha Underground. Despite his talents, he remains underutilized in WWE as a faction member rather than a solo competitor. With higher-profile singles matches, Mateo could demonstrate his real worth.
3. Grayson Waller
- Has potential to be a strong individual star
- Could excel as a midcard champion
Waller is frequently featured but undervalued for his full potential. He is a charismatic speaker and skilled wrestler who needs more opportunities outside of his current role to truly shine in 2026.
2. Rey Fenix
- Potential reunion with Lucha Brothers in WWE
- Not pushed enough as a singles star
When Fenix joined WWE, fans were excited about his speed and technique, yet the company hasn’t pushed him seriously. His impressive singles work in AEW shows what he’s capable of, and WWE could benefit from showcasing his talents more.
1. Carmelo Hayes
- Former NXT Champion
- Has succeeded whenever given a chance
Carmelo Hayes is one of WWE’s most gifted wrestlers, previously a top star in NXT with fans eagerly anticipating his rise on SmackDown. Yet, Hayes lacks a major title or storyline to elevate him further. With his personality and confidence, he just needs the right opportunity to stand out in 2026.
Fan Take: This list highlights WWE’s untapped potential within its roster, signaling that 2026 could be a transformative year for fresh and underrated talent. For fans, it means more exciting matchups and storylines that can revitalize the sport and bring new stars to the forefront.
