With two major wrestling promotions thriving again, it’s thrilling to watch top wrestlers switch between companies. Back in the 90s, stars like Hulk Hogan jumped to WCW from WWE. After WCW shut down in 2001, that excitement faded until AEW emerged in 2019, bringing fresh energy. Seeing talents like Bryan Danielson and Adam Cole debut in AEW simultaneously was electrifying, and WWE welcomed stars such as Penta, Rey Phoenix, and Jade Cargill, increasing the competition.
Recently, news broke that Mariah May was removed from AEW’s roster and is expected to join WWE soon. While this move puts her under a huge spotlight, there’s uncertainty if she will thrive there. Mariah, once a top female star in AEW and closely linked with Toni Storm, debuted in AEW in 2023 after gaining fame in Stardom. Instead of immediately pushing her to the top, AEW initially positioned her as Storm’s protégé, pairing them in a storyline that culminated in an intense feud for the AEW Women’s World Championship. She captured the title after winning the Owen Hart Cup, establishing herself as a compelling heel, but Storm reclaimed the belt in early 2024. Mariah’s last match in AEW took place at AEW Revolution in March, after which she disappeared from TV and was removed from AEW’s online roster.
Her departure was confirmed by Fightful Select, revealing her AEW contract, which lacked an option year, was close to expiration. AEW knew she was leaving, and WWE is reportedly taking steps to bring her onboard. While Mariah’s transition mirrors recent contract moves by stars like Ricky Starks and Ethan Page, WWE’s women’s division has grown increasingly packed with returning and rising talent such as Rhea Ripley, Liv Morgan, Jade Cargill, Becky Lynch, Iyo Sky, Tiffany Stratton, and recent main roster call-ups Roxanne Perez, Stephanie Vaquer, Giulia, and Jordynne Grace.
For Mariah, joining WWE is a gamble. Unlike in previous years when WWE’s women’s roster had fewer standouts, the current depth means she risks being overshadowed. To succeed, WWE must give her a prominent push from the start, avoiding relegation to NXT or midcard matches. Her talent and charisma demand a major spotlight, ideally challenging top stars like Rhea Ripley or Tiffany Stratton. Without this support, there’s a real chance she could get lost amid WWE’s crowded women’s division.
Fan Take: Mariah May’s move to WWE is a pivotal moment that highlights the increasing competition between wrestling promotions and the evolving landscape for female wrestlers. WWE fans should watch closely, as how the company handles her debut could set the tone for future talent acquisitions and the overall growth of women’s wrestling.
