BJ Rey made his return to the spotlight at WrestleCade 2025, but it wasn’t his fresh appearance that grabbed attention—it was a devastating body shot delivered by boxing legend Butterbean.
In a clip shared on BJ Rey’s Instagram, the former WWE LFG star can be seen backstage at a tournament, excitedly teasing Butterbean’s identity on camera. The playful challenge quickly turned serious when Butterbean responded without hesitation, landing a powerful body shot that knocked Rey to the ground in visible pain. The impact of the punch was so intense, it resonated throughout the venue, leaving no doubt about Butterbean’s still-impressive strength.
“This man says you’re Butterbean, but you’re not Butterbean. Prove it!” Rey had challenged. Butterbean’s reply was unmistakable proof, delivered by the force of the punch.
The moment quickly went viral, with fans applauding Butterbean’s toughness, Rey’s convincing reaction, and the comedic timing of the whole exchange. This event followed BJ Rey’s recent Instagram tease of a comeback, where he posted four photos reminiscent of his platinum blonde look with the caption: “I might have to chase that blonde away 😈.”
Between revisiting his iconic hairstyle and now becoming part of a viral WrestleCade moment, BJ Rey is ensuring he remains a central figure in the wrestling conversation, scars and all.
Do you believe BJ Rey’s WrestleCade moment was his peak return, or is there more to come? Share your thoughts on what you want to see next from him.
If you use this story, please credit Ringside News.
Fan Take: This news is a big deal for WWE fans because it meshes the charisma of wrestling with the raw power of boxing legend Butterbean, highlighting how crossover moments can breathe fresh energy into wrestling. BJ Rey’s willingness to embrace both his past and these surprising new challenges hints at exciting directions for his career and the sport’s evolving entertainment value.
