10 Unforgettable Female Rivals Who Shaped AEW’s Legacy

AEW has garnered acclaim for its high-quality matches and commitment to authentic professional wrestling, steering clear of the “sports entertainment” stigma. However, it’s widely recognized that the women’s division has been its Achilles’ heel.

While some attribute this to a lack of television time for women or question Tony Khan’s commitment, it’s undeniable that the women’s division has birthed some of AEW’s most compelling storylines over its six-year history.

With Texas events on the horizon, it feels appropriate to highlight the pivotal rivalries that have defined AEW’s women’s division. Join us as we dive into ten memorable feuds that have left a lasting impact on AEW’s storylines.

The rivalry between AEW’s inaugural women’s champions, Riho and Nyla Rose, is often considered a quintessential David vs. Goliath narrative. Riho, undersized at under 100 pounds yet with years of experience, faced off against Rose, a towering figure known as the “Native Beast” and the first transgender woman prominently featured in U.S. wrestling.

This feud ignited at Fyter Fest 2019, AEW’s second event, where Riho unexpectedly triumphed over Rose in a triple-threat match. Following that, Rose’s relentless pursuit for dominance culminated in her winning the Casino Battle Royal, granting her the chance to compete for the Women’s Championship in AEW’s first-ever “Dynamite.”

Though Riho secured the title first, her reign ended with Rose claiming the championship on February 12, 2020, solidifying her place in AEW history.

Dr. Britt Baker and Thunder Rosa’s feud is widely regarded as one of the most significant rivalries in AEW women’s history. Their story took off in the latter half of 2020, kicking off with Baker’s unsuccessful pursuit of Rosa’s NWA Championship.

The rivalry escalated with brawls and intense encounters, ultimately peaking during the St. Patrick’s Day Slam event in 2021, which became a benchmark for women’s wrestling. Their clash not only garnered praise from fans and critics but also helped elevate the women’s division as a whole.

While the two had periods of separation, their paths crossed again in 2022, including a championship match that led to Rosa becoming a fan favorite, further solidifying their legacy in AEW.

The compelling rivalry between Hikaru Shida and Serena Deeb stands out even without a championship on the line. Their competition began with Shida’s historic 50th AEW victory, sparking Deeb’s intense desire to prove herself against her.

This led to a five-match series, showcasing brutal encounters that demonstrated their skill and storytelling abilities. Their heated rivalry culminated in an epic finale that highlighted both women’s talents and set a high bar for future women’s matches in AEW.

The ongoing feud between Toni Storm and Jamie Hayter is fueled by their history within the UK’s indie scene and the escalating tension since Storm joined AEW in 2022. After a series of intense encounters, including a critically acclaimed match at Full Gear, their rivalry showcases some of the best physical storytelling in AEW.

With Hayter capturing the AEW Women’s Championship, fans are eager to see where this competitive dynamic will lead next, hinting that there’s still more to unfold in their contentious saga.

Although this rivalry began in Ring of Honor, it seamlessly transitioned into AEW as both Athena and Willow Nightingale now hold major roles in both promotions. Their contrasting styles and storylines converge, sealing a rivalry built on mutual respect and competitive spirit.

Athena’s determination to reclaim dominance against Willow adds depth to their rivalry, making fans eager to witness their ongoing saga. The chemistry between the two women cements their status as top-tier athletes in women’s wrestling.

Fans were eagerly anticipating the rivalry between Toni Storm and Mariah May, likening it to the iconic film “All About Eve.” The narrative sees Storm’s initial admiration for the younger May turn sour after May’s betrayal, leading to a thrilling rivalry that has resonated with audiences.

As the two continue to clash, their story unfolds dramatically, promising a blend of competition and emotional stakes that keeps fans glued to the action.

The friendship-turned-rivalry between Willow Nightingale and Kris Statlander has produced thrilling encounters, illustrating how top competitors can emerge from camaraderie. Their dynamic has evolved, especially with the championship stakes in mind, as Nightingale becomes a contender and Statlander seeks to reclaim her title.

This storyline, rooted in respect and competition, is poised to offer fans more dramatic moments as their relationship unfolds in the ring.

Upon her arrival in AEW in March 2024, Mercedes Monet made a significant impact, instantly raising the stakes in the women’s division. Her fierce rivalry with Kris Statlander showcases the best of women’s wrestling, as both athletes push each other to new heights.

With high-stakes battles not only for titles but also for pride, this rivalry promises to be one that resonates with fans and sets the stage for future encounters.

The budding rivalry between Mercedes Monet and Harley Cameron has captured attention through its unique blend of talent and charisma. Cameron’s rise as a fan-favorite contrasts Monet’s established dominance in the ring, setting up a compelling storyline that fans are eager to follow.

Their dynamic promises not only entertaining matches but also a showcase of character development that enhances the women’s division.

The rivalry set to unfold between Toni Storm and Mercedes Monet is poised to be one of the most significant in AEW’s history. Their upcoming match promises a clash of titans, as both champions face off, raising excitement and anticipation among fans.

With their contrasting styles and strong personalities, this feud could redefine the landscape of women’s wrestling in AEW, making it a crucial moment for the sport.