WWE SummerSlam 2025 kicked off on Saturday at MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, New Jersey, featuring a lineup packed with major title bouts, top stars, and gripping storylines. The event’s first night showcased a wide range of matches, varying greatly in quality.
Using TheSportster’s rating system, let’s break down the matches from WWE SummerSlam 2025, pinpointing the weakest bout and evaluating the rest.
Sami Zayn vs. Karrion Kross
Overall rating: 5.75/10
This match mirrored its build-up, receiving mixed reactions. Fans were skeptical about Sami Zayn’s turn to the Dark Side, which diminished the impact when he refused to use steel pipes and stayed true to his morals. Both competitors demonstrated strength, with Zayn effectively selling his frustration. Ultimately, Zayn defeated Kross.
Randy Orton & Jerry Roll vs. Drew McIntyre & Logan Paul
Overall rating: 6/10
Jerry Roll’s in-ring skills were not top-tier, impacting the match’s technical flow, though his character work and a dramatic splash through a table by Logan Paul were highlights. Despite an occasionally distracted crowd, especially during the middle portion, the match remained entertaining. Paul and McIntyre secured the win, preventing the celebrities from taking victory, which is atypical for WWE.
Judgment Day vs. Charlotte Flair & Alexa Bliss (WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship)
Overall rating: 6.75/10
Charlotte Flair and Alexa Bliss captured the WWE Women’s Tag Team titles after a competitive match against Raquel Rodriguez and Roxanne Perez. The bout had strong moments, especially with heel tactics from Judgment Day and evolving dynamics between Flair and Bliss. Though the pace slowed mid-match, the women ended strong and received a robust reaction at the finish.
Tiffany Stratton vs. Jade Cargill (WWE Women’s Championship)
Overall rating: 7/10
Despite limited experience, Tiffany Stratton and Jade Cargill delivered an engaging contest, with Stratton pulling off a surprising clean win. The match was fast-paced, showcasing athleticism and chemistry, with only minor errors. Cargill still impressed as one of the night’s standout performers.
Roman Reigns & Jay Uso vs. Bronson Reed & Bron Breakker
Overall rating: 7.5/10
This bout played out as expected, with the villains dominating before Roman Reigns made a crucial hot tag to Jay Uso. The pacing was sometimes slow but the crowd stayed invested, applauding the storytelling and the roles played. Uso clinched victory with a spear and splash, ending the match on an exciting note.
Gunther vs. CM Punk (World Heavyweight Championship)
Overall rating: 8.75/10
In a deliberate, old-school style main event, CM Punk and Gunther engaged in a strategic battle focusing on technical skill, submissions, and counters. Punk was a spirited babyface against Gunther’s imposing champion presence. The match flowed with tension and occasional bursts of action, captivating the audience. Punk, despite bleeding, triumphed to become the new World Heavyweight Champion. The night ended with Seth Rollins cashing in his Money in the Bank briefcase in a surprising twist, defeating Punk shortly after, adding another dramatic layer to the showdown.
Fan Take:
This event was pivotal as it showcased both rising stars and established veterans, setting the stage for exciting rivalries ahead. The surprising title changes and cash-in moments not only thrilled fans but also promise a dynamic future for WWE’s storytelling and competition.
