In 2016, WWE hosted its first women’s main event at a pay-per-view as part of the ongoing “Women’s Revolution.” However, rather than becoming a regular feature, women’s main events have only been sporadic over the following nine years. Using TheSportster’s ratings compared with Wrestling Observer Newsletter, cagematch.net, and Dave Meltzer’s evaluations, the quality of these women’s PPV main events ranges widely.
10. Becky Lynch vs. Bayley vs. Shayna Baszler at WWE Survivor Series 2019 received a low overall score of 5.25/10, with storytelling and crowd reaction notably weak. Despite the presence of three women’s champions, the match failed to engage the audience or build suspense, ending in an anticlimactic win for Baszler.
9. Shayna Baszler vs. Asuka vs. Natalya vs. Ruby Riott vs. Liv Morgan vs. Sarah Logan at WWE Elimination Chamber 2020 also scored 5.25/10 but was criticized for its bland story and uninspiring character moments, culminating in Baszler sweeping the match with little fan investment.
8. Ronda Rousey vs. Charlotte Flair vs. Becky Lynch at WrestleMania 35 earned 6/10. The match had a compelling storyline about overcoming odds but struggled with pace, sloppy in-ring work, and lacked crowd excitement despite Lynch’s win.
7. Kabuki Warriors vs. Becky Lynch & Charlotte Flair at WWE TLC 2019 was rated 6.25/10. It showcased some exciting spots but was marred by a mishap that caused one wrestler’s injury, resulting in a messy finish. Asuka and Kairi Sane won, ending the match on a less-than-perfect note.
6. Ronda Rousey vs. Nikki Bella at WWE Evolution 2018 scored 6.5/10, featuring a contest of contrasting styles. Neither were elite wrestlers, but they outperformed expectations, with Bella’s tactics adding interest to the bout.
5. Rhea Ripley vs. Nia Jax at WWE Elimination Chamber 2024 achieved 6.75/10. Set in Australia, the predictable match was simple yet effective, with Ripley overcoming Jax in front of a supportive hometown crowd.
4. Sasha Banks vs. Charlotte Flair at WWE Hell in a Cell 2016 gained a 7/10 rating. Despite a botched finish, the physical and innovative match had a strong fight atmosphere and memorable moments.
3. The Women’s Royal Rumble Match in 2018 was rated 7.5/10. This historic and celebratory event featured a blend of veterans and new stars, creating consistent crowd engagement despite technical flaws.
2. Becky Lynch vs. Charlotte Flair vs. Asuka at WWE TLC 2018 received 8/10 for its entertaining and technically solid performance. Lynch and Flair’s rivalry drove the story, culminating in Asuka’s satisfying victory.
1. Sasha Banks vs. Bianca Belair at WrestleMania 37 was rated the highest at 8.75/10. Their dynamic match combined technical skill, brutal storytelling, and electrifying crowd response, crowned by Belair’s breakthrough win.
Fan Take: These evaluations highlight the significant strides women’s wrestling has made in WWE, underscoring important moments that have captured fan interest and spotlighted female talent. As the sport evolves, consistent top-tier women’s main events can not only boost WWE’s appeal but also inspire the future generation of wrestlers.
